Applying Analytical Hierarchy Process to Evaluate Adult Occupant Protection on Body Region in ASEAN NCAP Offset Frontal Test Domain

H. A. Aziz, E. H. Sukadarin, N. S. Suhaimi, H. Osman, M. N. Noordin and I. Shafiee

Abstract: Adult Occupant Protection (AOP) is a vital area of evaluation in all New Car Assessment Programs (NCAPs) around the globe. The primary objective of these new car assessment programs is to reduce road deaths by focusing on vehicle (pre-crash) safety features. Starting from the year 2017 until 2020, a single rating system has been introduced whereby AOP contributes 50% to the overall rating with a maximum of 36 points; split into three main domains including offset frontal test (OFT), side impact test (SIT) and head protection technology (HPT). However, the extent of OFT protection to car drivers and passengers during a collision still needs to be explored. Therefore, in this study, an evaluation of body region injury due to AOP failure in frontal crash is conducted to validate and support NCAP rating. Analytic hierarchy process (AHP) is put forward on the basis of expert’s input from various related fields to evaluate the injury to body regions and OFT protection during an accident based on the current situation. The results show that head, neck and chest indicated the highest severity, followed by knee, femur and lower leg with respect to the Consistency Ratio (CR) of 0.0633. This was in line with the focus of ASEAN NCAP’s AOP protocol whereby the three body regions were deemed as the critical parts and required sufficient protection. Based on the findings, it is proven that ASEAN NCAP’s consideration of OFT in AOP is well developed and suits the current needs.

Keywords:Adult Occupant Protection, Offset Frontal Test, AHP, expert assessment


Aguaron, J, & Moreno-Jimenez, J.M. (2003). The geometric consistency index: Approximated thresholds. European Journal Operation Research, 147(1), 137-145.

Antona-Makoshia, J., Mikamia, K., Lindkvistb, M., Davidssonc, J., & Schickd, S. (2018). Accident analysis to support the development of strategies for the prevention of brain injuries in car crashes. Accident Analysis and Prevention, 117, 98-105.

ASEAN NCAP (2017). Assessment protocol – Adult occupant protection. Selangor, Malaysia: New Car Assessment Program for Southeast Asian Countries (ASEAN NCAP). Retrieved from Occupant-Protection-Assessment-Protocol-Version-1.0-FINAL.pdf

Aziz, H.A., Othman, M.R., Shariff, A.M., & Tan, L.S. (2017) Application of analytical hierarchy process (AHP) in prioritizing HAZOP analysis for pilot plant. Chemical Engineering Research Bulletin, 19, 87-95.

Johannsen, H., Adolph, T., Edwards, M., Lazaro, I., Versmissen, T., & Thomson, R. (2013). Proposal for a frontal impact and compatibility assessment approach based on the European FIMCAR project. Traffic Injury Prevention, 14, s105-s115.

Ministry of Transport Malaysia (2017). Transport statistic Malaysia 2016. Putrajaya: Ministry of Transport Malaysia (MOT). Retrieved from maklumat/statistik-tahunan-pengangkutan

Mohd Jawi, Z., Abu Kassim, K.A., & Mohd Sadullah, A.F. (2013). ASEAN NCAP – The best bet for vehicle safety in the region’s safe system. International Journal of Trade, Economics and Finance, 4(6), 358-363.

Othman, M.R., Hady, L., Repke, J.U., & Wozny, G. (2012) Introducing sustainability assessment and selection (SAS) into chemical engineering education. Education Chemical Engineering, 7(3), e118- e124.

Saaty, T.L. (1980). The Analytic Hierarchy Process. New York: McGraw-Hill.

van Ratingen, M., Williams, A., Lie, A., Seeck, A., Pierre Castaing, P., Kolke, R., Adriaenssens, G., & Miller, A. (2016). The European New Car Assessment Programme: A historical review. Chinese Journal of Traumatology, 19, 63-69.

Xi, J., Zhao, Z., Li, W., & Wang, Q. (2016). A traffic accident causation analysis method based on AHP-Apriori. Procedia Engineering, 137, 680-687.

WHO (2013). Global status report on road safety 2013: Supporting a decade of action. Geneva: World Health Organization (WHO).